Wednesday, May 31, 2017

Alternate ITS missions part 2

Unfortunately, this post will have to be broken into three parts, since I started looking into how life support worked, and the post got really long. This part will mostly be about life support, and the next one will have details on actual missions.

There are two primary ways to support humans in space with oxygen, food, and water: ecological, and chemical. Ecological uses plants to reprocess human waste, carbon dioxide, and trace nutrients into food, and humans to process food and oxygen into what the plants need, making a closed loop, as long as you have sunlight.
The largest problem with this is that the amount of plants required to support one person's oxygen needs would produce about half the required food for that person. If you have enough plants to provide enough food, half of them die off due to lack of carbon dioxide.

Chemical life support uses chemical reactors to crack carbon dioxide into oxygen, and extract usable water from sweat and urine. The problem with this is that you must pack all the food you will need.

Storage of oxygen is simple, as you can use boiloff from the main oxidizer tanks. 

The air on Earth at sea level is at 101kpa. The atmosphere is 21% oxygen, so the partial pressure of oxygen is 21.21kpa. 

Partial pressure, in a mix of gases, is how much pressure one of the gases would be under if all other gases were removed.
The minimum safe partial pressure of oxygen is 16kpa, and the maximum is somewhere between 50 and 100 kpa for short periods of time (a few hours). For long term breathing atmosphere, you want to stay under 50 kpa, ideally at about 21 kpa. 

A high pressure pure oxygen environment is very dangerous because of fire, the Apollo 1 fire happened in a pure oxygen environment at 115kpa, this is what wood burning in a 50 kpa partial pressure environment looks like: https://youtu.be/_JkHB1hV7Hw?t=1m After that all US manned spacecraft used a 79% nitrogen/21% oxygen environment at about 101kpa.

So why was the Apollo 1 command module pressurized to 115 kpa? Because it was designed to hold pressure in, not out. During launch, the pressure would have gradually been reduced to 34 kpa. I don't know whether the ITS will use a nitrogen/oxygen mix, or pure oxygen which is always kept at safe pressures, but either way it will take about 0.85kg/day of oxygen, as nitrogen is not consumed when inhaled.

A larger problem than oxygen is carbon dioxide. Every astronaut exhales about 1 kg of it a day, and if it rises above 0.5% concentration it can become a serious danger. However, 0.273 kg of that is carbon, so most of it can be breathed again if it is cracked back into carbon and oxygen. 

There are two options for dealing with carbon dioxide, cracking and scrubbing. Scrubbing uses a catalyst, which removes carbon dioxide from the air, producing water. It can be cleaned and used again by blowing hot air through it for 10 hours, however, you lose all that oxygen locked in the carbon dioxide.

A chemical reactor would use the sabatier reaction, like the ISS. 
CO2 + 4H2 → CH4 + 2H2O
Exhaled CO2 would be processed with hydrogen to produce CH4 (methane) and water. The water can be electrolyzed into H2 and O2, and the CH4 can be pyrolized into C and H2. The hydrogen outputs can be fed back into the sabatier reactor, closing the loop. It would probably not be perfectly efficient, but since you only need about 180 grams of H2 for every kg or CO2 processed, even at 90% efficiency you would only need to add 18 grams of hydrogen a day.

However, every crew member exhales 1 kg of carbon dioxide/day, but only 0.727 kg of that is oxygen. That means that you have to add 108 grams of oxygen every day.

Astronauts need to drink about 3.9 kg of water every day, some mixed in with their food, if it isn't freeze-dried, and about 26 kg/day of water for personal hygiene. Most of the waste water (grey water, human waste, sweat) can be distilled and filtered. I estimate that about 0.1 kg of water would be lost in recovery every day.

Astronauts on the ISS eat about 2.5 kg of food every day, which consists of a mix of different kinds of food, mostly freeze-dried or otherwise stabilized. Some of it is fresh.

For the purposes of this, we can assume that all non-reusable waste (packaging, filters, solid human waste) is non-existent, as it can be dumped overboard between burns. If you wished to prevent the build up of trash in solar orbit you could dump it only while on a collision course with a planet, however that would likely only be a problem on trips that would be taken frequently.


Weights required:
5 tons for storage, processing equipment, etc.100 grams of water x mission length in days18 grams of H2 x mission length in days108 grams of oxygen x mission length in days x crew members2.5 kg of food x mission length in days x crew members


In a CELSS (Closed (or Controlled) ecological life support system), rather than using chemical reactors, the life support loop is fully closed, like Earth's ecosystem. 

If you could get a CELSS working properly, it has the potential to be much more mass efficient than chemical life support system, with the crossover point for efficiency at around 2 years, according to Rocketpunk Manifesto. However, in their current state, they have some problems. For many plants, the amount of plants needed to provide food for astronauts is different for the amount need to provide oxygen, so the imbalance would cause an excess of oxygen, which would kill some of the plants, and then there wouldn't be enough food.

One of the most promising crops is Spirulina, a type of blue-green algae that, Marshall T. Savage claims in The Millennial Project, could close the life support loop almost fully with only 6 liters of algae per person (about 6.6 kg). (Note: I haven't read that book, this is taken from Atomic Rockets)
Even if you needed twice that much per person it would be very impressive.

For the purposes of this analysis, however, I will stick to existing methods of food production, as the goal is to use the fact that the ITS would be flying regularly to study a mission that could be much cheaper than a spacecraft designed only for the purpose of that mission. 

In the next part we will finally look at the actual mission profiles.

Sunday, April 30, 2017

Alternate ITS missions part 1

The Interplanetary Transport System is a spacecraft concept developed by SpaceX and designed to colonize Mars. While it is designed for that specific goal, it could feasibly be adapted to other missions. This post, part 1, talks about the performance of the ITS, and the second part will talk about what missions it is capable of.

The ITS has two configurations, the ship, and the tanker. The ship is designed to carry 450t or 100 people to Mars, while the tanker is designed to refuel the ship in Earth orbit.

Let's take a closer look at the performance.

First of all, the maximum delta-v.
Using the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation (DV = Ve*ln(minitial/mfinal)) like so:

DV =  3,747.42*ln(2100/150) = 9889 m/s

This is an impressively high delta-v, however it assumes no payload, with the standard ITS configuration (not the tanker).

With the tanker configuration:

DV = 3,747.42*ln(2590/90)  = 12589 m/s

This also assumes no payload.


You can calculate how much delta-v you need for transfers between planets with a porkchop plot, or you could just use a handy delta-v map of the solar system that assumes reasonably efficient transfers.

(Chart from Atomic Rockets)


We can reverse the rocket equation to find out how much payload we can carry, given a specific required delta-v. Wolfram|alpha can do this for us easily, and the answer is mfinal = minitial*ℯ-DV/VE
ℯ = Euler's constant, or ~2.71.

Payload equals mfinal - empty mass
Empty mass differs between the tanker and the standard ITS configuration by 60t. It's hard to tell what of that is necessary for a much smaller crew, as might be used on these missions. A safe bet is probably around 120t, halfway between the two numbers.

Propellant mass also differs, with 1950t for the ship and 2500t for the tanker. In this case, to keep costs low, the ship value of 1950t would be used, as there is no space for crew in the tanker, and changing the size and shape of the composite tanks is expensive.

Note that while SpaceX uses a value of 6km/s from low earth orbit (LEO) to trans-Mars injection (TMI), more efficient (but slower) transfers use on the order of 3-4km/s. Presumably, this is done to minimize life support costs; both consumables and radiation shielding. However, if you're sending 5 people instead of 100, consumable costs per day only scale 1/20 as fast per unit time, so almost any other missions would sacrifice travel speed for payload.

The ITS has 3 sea level Raptor engines, and 6 vacuum Raptors. Basically, in a vacuum you could use the sea level engines in addition to the vacuum engines, but it would just hurt our delta-v. In an atmosphere, you can't use the vacuum engines due to flow separation, which happens when your engine is overexpanded. (flow separation is an extreme example of what causes the space shuttle main engines to wobble as they start up, as they have to be efficient throughout the entire atmosphere: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDCCBgppG4s)

So the ITS has different thrust-to-weight ratios (TWR) for different situations.

3*SL Raptor = 9150kn =  933 metric tons-force = empty TWR of 7.775
= loaded TWR of 0.45

6*VAC Raptor = 21000kn =  2141 metric tons-force = empty TWR of 17.84
= loaded TWR of 1.03

Max possible thrust in VAC = 3074 metric tons-force = empty TWR of 25.62
= loaded TWR of 1.49

These are all assuming you're on Earth, with no payload.

The ITS can withstand 10-15gs, and a minimum of 1,700 degrees C.

In the next part we will go over what missions the ITS could perform now that we have determined its performance.


Friday, March 31, 2017

Buran


This is not the Space Shuttle. This is Buran. Buran was a soviet project from 1974, to build a craft that could counter a perceived military threat from the US Space Shuttle. It was believed by the designers of Buran that the shuttle's entire purpose was military due to its large cargo capacity.



(Left to right: Soyuz, Space Shuttle, Buran)

Surprisingly, it appears that no espionage was involved in the development of Buran other than external photos, as there are are many differences between the two spacecraft.

Most notably, it did not have an external tank which had no engines on it like the space shuttle, rather it launched piggyback on a Energia rocket which had its own engines. Also, rather than using two solid strap-on boosters, it had four liquid oxygen-kerosene strap-on boosters.

It also used two liquid oxygen-kerosene engines for maneuvers in orbit, rather than MMH/N2O4 engines.



Buran made its first and last flight in 15 Novemeber 1988. It was entirely unmanned for the entire flight, and worked perfectly, despite landing in crosswinds of 38 mph (61.2 kph). After that the project was put on hold, and finally cancelled in 1993. The only Buran to have flown, OK-1K1, was destroyed in 2002 when the roof of the hangar it was stored in collapsed.


There were four other flight articles (craft that were built to fly), and a handful of test articles for various systems. Wikipedia has a full list here.

Ralph Mirebs took pictures of two of the remaining flight articles, which you can see here.

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

Nuclear rockets

One of the most important measures of rocket engines is specific impulse, which is just how efficiently a engine burns fuel. It is almost the same thing as exhaust velocity, which is how fast the exhaust stream is going when it leaves the engine.

Most rockets use chemical engines which combine a fuel and an oxidizer to accelerate the exhaust products and provide thrust. Isps of chemical rockets max out at about 450 seconds. Nuclear thermal rockets get Isp from 900 seconds on up. This is because their exhaust velocity is not limited by the energy of a chemical reaction, as they use the heat from a nuclear reaction to accelerate hydrogen by expanding it inside the core of a reactor.

This is the simplest type of nuclear thermal propulsion, and NASA did some tests on it in the '50s and '60s. The problem is that it's performance is limited by the melting point of the reactor. There are a couple of types of nuclear thermal propulsion that avoid this problem in various ways:

Twisted ribbon, pebble bed

By changing the shape of the fuel rods in the reactor, you can increase the heat transfer to the propellant. Twisted ribbon looks like this:


Pebble bed reactors are made out of "pebbles" of fuel that look like this;




Pulsed solid-core

This type of engine works by pulsing the power at which the reactor runs at from its normal power level to far beyond what the materials that it is made could withstand. As the temperatures are momentary, the cooling system can keep it from melting down. This is even better than it sounds, as neutrons generated while it is at maximum power will heat the propellant even further.

Liquid core

Solving the problem of preventing your reactor from melting down by designing it to run while molten! Outside-the-box thinking.
Problem include keeping your molten core from escaping with the propellent.

Isp 1,500 seconds.

Gas core

The logical extension of the liquid core design by allowing the uranium to turn not just liquid but to gas.

The problem of preventing the uranium plasma from escaping is exacerbated with gas core.

Isps 1,800 seconds to 7,000 seconds with advanced designs.

Nuclear lightbulb



It works like an easybake oven, except the lightbulb is a uranium plasma contained by a quartz vessel that doesn't melt because quartz is transparent to the majority of the radiation that is emitted, and the cake is hydrogen travelling at 20 km/s. Ages 10 and up.

Isps between 2,000 and 3,000 seconds.


Fission fragment

This skips a separate propellant entirely and uses the split atoms from the fission as propellant. The original concept used discs coated with the fuel, but a more efficient design uses ground-up fuel (around 100 nanometers) which are magnetically contained before they fission.

Isp 100,000 to 1,000,000 seconds.


Nuclear pulse

Uses nuclear bombs as propulsion, by dropping them behind a strong plate that dampens the shock and heat enough that anyone on board doesn't die. It apparently would work, and was even tested with conventional explosives. Development stopped mostly due to the nuclear test ban treaty and that this is best suited to lift spacecraft from the ground to orbit.
[This] is not nuts, [this] is super-nuts
-Richard Courant on viewing an nuclear pulse engine test

Isp 4,000 to 7,000 (with fusion bombs)


Nuclear salt water

This is one of the most crazy concepts for a rocket engine ever made. Its fuel is 20% enriched uranium mixed at 2% with water. It is stored in tubes coated with some kind of moderator which prevents it from reaching critical mass inside the tanks. When it is injected into the combustion chamber, the uranium reaches critical mass and begins a nuclear detonation. This can be sustained with more of the fuel being injected into the chamber. This has the advantage of the nuclear pulse engine's high efficiency, with continuous thrust and the ability to work at small scales.